I was 16 years old, and had just arrived in the USA. John asked me my favorite sport. I replied, “football.” When I learned that he also loved “football,” we launched into an animated conversation that became quite confusing. Only when I remembered that the word “football” in the USA was used for a sport where a funny-looking ball is carried by hand and seldom kicked, and that most Americans referred to what I called “football” as “soccer,” were we able to carry on a meaningful conversation where we actually understood what our conversation partner was talking about.
A global conversation about “witches” and “witchcraft” easily becomes every bit as confusing, and for the same reason. Different people use the same words to talk about fundamentally different and even unrelated realities. For example, in America and Europe there are new forms of religion (Wicca, Neopaganism) whose adherents publically identify themselves as “witches.” These “witches” typically adhere to feminist and ecological values and to the ethic of “first do no harm.” Such “witches” occasionally write a letter to the editor of an African newspaper, asking why local governments do not fully protect the rights of “witches” to practice their craft as they wish. Such letters assume a fixed meaning for the term witch and misconstrue the meaning of the term as it is used in most of Africa. Like John and me talking “football,” we use the same word, but unknowingly talk about completely different realities.
Defining “Witch”
Of course historically most of the world did not speak English. So this should not be primarily a discussion about the “true meaning” of the English word “witch” or “sorcerer/sorceress”. And yet anthropologists discovered across hundreds of languages and cultures a widespread (although not universal) lexically distinguished idea, the idea that misfortunes and deaths were caused by malicious human third parties making socially disapproved use of occult/supernatural power to harm or kill others. In some cultures there was a distinction between those who harmed others with innate psychic power, sometimes exercised unconsciously, and those who harmed others through power (consciously) exercised through the manipulation of learned magical techniques. Following the lead of Evans-Pritchard, many anthropologists reserved the term “witch” to translate indigenous terms for those understood as using innate or psychic power to harm others, and the term “sorcerer/sorceress” for those understood as consciously using learned and acquired magical techniques to harm others. But since most cultures do not consistently maintain this distinction, it is common today for the term “witch” to be used by anthropologists for any person, male or female, believed to have caused the misfortune of others through psychic, magical, or other occult power. When the term “sorcerer/sorceress” is used, it often has a slightly more restricted focus and refers to people using learned and acquired magical technique to bring about harm to others.
Defining “Witchdoctor”
In societies that attribute misfortune and death to human parties identified as witches or sorcerers, there is often also another category of magico-religious practitioner who acts with social approval to combat the witch or sorcerer/sorceress. Indigenous terms for this other category of magico-religious practitioner have often been translated into English as “traditional healer,” “witchdoctor,” “diviner,” “shaman,” or “medicine man.” In most societies historically that had both “witches” (mchawi) and “witchdoctors” (mganga), the “witch” was thought of as acting towards anti-social ends — towards the harm of others, and the “witchdoctor” or “shaman” as acting towards pro-social ends — towards the healing of others. And, prior to the presence of Christianity, in most societies both the evil “witch” and the good “witchdoctor” were thought of as drawing from the same source(s) of power — which were neither intrinsically evil nor intrinsically good.
Christianity and the Supernatural
That is, in most societies historically, while there was often a concept of a “high god,” there was not a Satan concept, a concept of a thoroughly evil non-human supernatural being opposed to God and the good — with all supernatural power thought to be either intrinsically good and from God, or evil and from Satan. Thus, prior to the influence of Christianity, moral judgment of the power being exercised was not normally based on whether the power was thought to come from God or Satan.
Finally, it should be pointed out that in most cultures with both the figure of the “witch” and that of the “witchdoctor” set in opposition to each other, it was not only these two categories of person that were thought to exercise supernatural power. A wide range of other magico-religious practices were also carried out by a range of people who themselves were not identified either by the indigenous term for witch/sorcerer or by the indigenous term for witchdoctor/shaman. Gardening magic, fishing magic, hunting magic, fertility magic, the protective use of charms or amulets, ancestral rites and libations, marriage rites, puberty rites, love magic, the use of magic for entertainment purposes, or predictions about the future might be carried out by virtually anyone with the requisite knowledge, or by yet other named categories of practitioners with specialized power and knowledge. Figure 1 shows the common assumed pattern in many traditional societies prior to the influence of Christianity.
Notice that the single agreed-upon locus of moral evil involved the image of the human witch/sorcerer. Here there is no image of a non-human supernatural Satan figure. Thus all sorts of magico-religious practices that were not associated with the witch or sorcerer were not thought of as necessarily evil, and their practitioners were not understood as intending harm to others.
With the influential presence of Christianity came pressures for change in fundamental assumptions. Under Christian understandings it was often felt that any genuine supernatural power must be either of God, and thus good, or of Satan, and thus intrinsically anti-God and anti-good.
The traditional image of the witch was easily understood as associated with Satan — since both were understood as evil. Indeed, since indigenous languages usually lacked words that closely fit the idea of Satan, it was often words associated with human witches or witchcraft that were used to translate the idea of Satan, as with the Adioukrou of Côte d’Ivoire, where the indigenous word for “witchcraft,” agn, is now used by Christians for “the devil.” Similarly, the anthropologist Birgit Meyer, in her book Translating the Devil (1999), documents how early missionaries to the Ewe of Ghana translated Satan as Abonsam, an Akan term which she says was originally understood by the Ewe as a synonym for “witch.” Every Ewe Christian reference to Satan thus becomes simultaneously a reference to, and ratification of, the witch idea. But whether or not words meaning “witch” were used to translate the idea of Satan, the associations between the two were easily and frequently made.
And since traditionally the “witchdoctor” was thought to have the same power as that of the witch, if the witch’s power was of Satan, then so must the witchdoctor’s power be. And because “witchdoctors” were thought to have the same power as the witch even before the presence of Christianity, they were often suspected of secretly being witches themselves. That is, the image of the witchdoctor was often a somewhat ambiguous image to start with, which made the claim that witchdoctors were really deriving their power from Satan persuasive for many Christians. Furthermore, if all magico-religious power necessarily came from either God or Satan, then all traditional forms of magico-religious practice and power must be categorized as of Satan or of God.
Perhaps the single best scholarly resource that describes in a contemporary context the transformations of older ideas about witchcraft and magic under the influence of Christian and especially Pentecostal and “third wave” ideas about spiritual warfare, is the recent book by Opoku Onyinah, Pentecostal Exorcism: Witchcraft and Demonology in Ghana (Deo Publishing, 2012). This ought to be essential reading for all of us wishing to think through these issues.
Reconfiguring Witchcraft
Not only in Ghana, but in many societies that historically had the image of the witch and that have been influenced by Christianity, a reconfigured conceptualization of supernatural realities begins to look like this (figure 2).
Under such a reconfiguring, not only the traditional healer, but anyone who has poured out libations at a wedding or who has used a charm or amulet, is likely to be identified as practicing “witchcraft” — and may be suspected of what witches traditionally are thought to do, bringing harm and death to others. That is, a concept that originally constituted only a sub-set of traditional magico-religious practices, is now reframed as the master category for all such practices. Now anyone making any use of any traditional magico-religious practice, will be suspected of being a witch — someone who harms and kills others. This naturally involves a rather significant expansion of the meaning of the term witchcraft and of the number of people likely to be treated as witches.
Furthermore, this new way of conceptualizing witchcraft encourages pastors or other Christian leaders to claim the powers traditionally claimed by “witchdoctors” — that is, the power to name certain people as witches, and the power to combat their witchcraft. Naturally there are many issues here that merit consideration.
But in this post my primary concern is to help us start a conversation about the meanings we have for the words we use. My own inclination, both because it best fits the empirical realities cross-culturally, and because of historical and anthropological precedent, is to reserve the term “witch” and “sorcerer/sorceress” for persons accused of being the cause of someone else’s misfortune or death. Because there are many cultures that have magico-religious practices that no one in the culture thinks has anything to do with harming others, I do not think it is helpful to expand the term witchcraft to include all magico-religious practices that are not Christian. I prefer to retain other terms (such as magic, or magico-religious) to describe these other practices.
Returning to the word “witch”
But it is also important to understand how people in given settings are actually using words. And in many contemporary settings (as among Ghanaian Pentecostals) the word “witch” or “witchcraft” involves a broadened range of meaning inclusive of many magico-religious practices not originally conceptualized as involving harm to anyone. By contrast, among Wiccans and Neopagans, the term “witch” is thought to describe a person with feminist, ecological, and life-affirming magico-religious values and practices grounded in an ethic of not harming anyone. So, when having a conversation with any specific group of people, it will be important to accurately understand and adjust to their usage of vocabulary and what that vocabulary means to them — even where I do not believe their vocabulary is particularly helpful analytically for understanding realities cross-culturally.
As we continue this conversation we will want to constantly reflect on the meaning of terms sometimes translated as “witch/witchcraft” or “witchdoctor” — whether those terms are in Swahili, Ewe, Kamba, French, Portuguese, Spanish, Hebrew, or Greek. In my next post on this topic I will invite us to consider various biblical passages and terms (such as kashaph ormagos) and the diverse ways in which these have been translated not only into Latin or English, but into Korean, Mandarin, Swahili, Sukuma, Ewe, Yoruba, or Kamba.
In the mean time, why not purchase and begin reading your own copy of Opoku Onyinah’s (2012) book, Pentecostal Exorcism: Witchcraft and Demonology in Ghana?
i want to share my amazing experience with Dr Jumba my husband was cheating on me and when i found out we had a fight which lead to him filling for a divorce i cried and fell sick when i was searching about love quotes online i saw people talking about him and his great work whose case was similar to mine they left his contact info i contacted him and he told me not to worry that after 24hrs he will cancel the divorce and be back to me after i did everything he asked me to do to my greatest surprise the next day evening it was my husband, he knelt down begging me to accept him back,thank you once again Dr Jumba you are indeed a blessing to me he can also help you contact
[email protected] or https://drjumbaspellhome.wordpress.com . +1 908 517 4108
HOW I GOT MY HUSBAND BACK
My name is Lori. i just want to share my experience with the world on how DR MARIAN, A great spell caster with 35 years plus experience and specialization in love spell casting got my lover back and saved my marriage easily. I was married for 7 years with 4 kids and we lived happily until things started getting ugly and we started having fights and arguments almost every time… it got worse at a point that he filed for a divorce… I tried my best to make him change his mind & stay with me cause i loved him with all my heart and didn’t want to loose him but everything just didn’t work out… he moved out of the house and still went ahead to file for divorce… I pleaded and tried everything but still nothing worked. The breakthrough came when someone introduced me to this wonderful, great spell caster DR MARIAN, who eventually helped me out… I have never been a fan of things like this but just decided to try reluctantly cause I was so desperate and left with no choice… DR MARIAN did special prayers and did cast a love spell on him. Within 24hours he called me and he was sorry for all the emotional trauma he had cost me, he moved back to the house and we continued to live happily, the kids are happy too and we are expecting our fourth child… I have introduced him to a lot of couples with problems across the world and they have had good news and testimonies too… Just thought I should share my experience cause I strongly believe someone out there needs it and i urge you not to give up as DR MARIAN is the right one to help you as he has proven worthy to so many of us already. You can contact him via:
EMAIL : [email protected]
WHATSAPP : +2349160402535
Strong And Powerful Love Spell To Win Your Ex Back.. I have decided that i am going to spend the whole day on the internet just to make sure that a lot of people are able to read this my testimony about Dr.happy who is a powerful spell caster, After been abandon by my husband i was so lonely, that i decided to go through the internet for some relationships tips, I never knew that this was the road map that will secure the return of my husband. After reading a lot of tips on how to restore my relationship in a more better way i discovered that Dr.happy has a lot of recommendation than other spell casters, So with this i had my mind made up that Dr.happy was the right person for this, And i contacted Dr.happy through his details which i saw on the internet and i was so happy that i chose to work with Dr.happy because his work was 100% perfect and the spell brought my husband back to me with fast relief you can also contact him for help now email.. [email protected]
Whatsapp/cal +2347068494711
Website…happylovespell2.webnode.com/
His facebook page https://web.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61552907003445
Strong And Powerful Love Spell To Win Your Ex Back.. I have decided that i am going to spend the whole day on the internet just to make sure that a lot of people are able to read this my testimony about Dr.happy who is a powerful spell caster, After been abandon by my husband i was so lonely, that i decided to go through the internet for some relationships tips, I never knew that this was the road map that will secure the return of my husband. After reading a lot of tips on how to restore my relationship in a more better way i discovered that Dr.happy has a lot of recommendation than other spell casters, So with this i had my mind made up that Dr.happy was the right person for this, And i contacted Dr.happy through his details which i saw on the internet and i was so happy that i chose to work with Dr.happy because his work was 100% perfect and the spell brought my husband back to me with fast relief you can also contact him for help now email.. [email protected]
Whatsapp/cal +2347068494711
Website…happylovespell2.webnode.com/
His facebook page https://web.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61552907003445
You can save your relationship if you are willing to do so” All thanks to Dr.Excellent spell caster for helping me to bring back my husband. I was heart broken when my husband left me and moved to California to be with another woman. I felt my life was over and my kids thought they would never see their father again. I tried to be strong just for the kids but I could not control the pains that tormented my heart, my heart was filled with sorrows and pains because I was really in love with my husband. I have tried many options but he did not come back, until i met a friend that directed me to Dr.Excellent a spell caster, who helped me to bring back my husband after 11hours. Me and my husband are living happily together again, This man is powerful, I will advice anyone that have relationship problem or marriage problem, financial Difficulty, court case problem to contact Dr Excellent now for help, Here his contact.
WhatsApp him at: +2348084273514 “Or email him at: [email protected] ,
His website:https://drexcellentspellcaster.godaddysites.com
Its a pleasure for me to write this testimony about how i got my Ex Husband a month ago. i have been reading so many good comments of some people who were help by Dr Adoda which i believe . I was hurt and depressed, I was too curious and wanted to try Dr.Adoda when i had issues with my husband, then i contacted him through his website (http://dradodalovetemple.com) when i contact him, he assured me 100% that he will bring him back, i pleaded with him to help me out. to My greatest suprise he did a successful love spell for me, and require me to do something which i agreed with him. To my greatest surprise i got a good result after 48hours i contacted him, i am really happy that i am with my ex husband again. I have waited for 2years to be with him again. So i guess its time i recommend anyone going through Relationship/ marriage problems should reach him through his Email ( [email protected] )
I am so excited to let the word know how Dr Kuda help me cured my dangerous sickness Herpes Simplex it all hard for me i went to several hospital to cure my Herpes and the doctor’s said to me that I will not be cure again that I will be coming to receive a treatment every one week and that is all precure my health I was so frustrated I have no other option then to take the treatment every week’s I am passing through all this complete 3years, until one day when I was going to the hospital to collect the weekly treatment a woman tell me how Dr Kuda helped her to cure her son from Hiv sickness that she is very sure that Dr Kuda we definitely help me in my condition right now so I collected Dr Kuda number to seek for his help and I was so gald when Dr Kuda said that he will prepare herbal medicine and send it to me after some days I received the herbal medicine from him, Dr Kuda give me instrection how to take it only two weeks after some days I should go to confirm it, and was genuine what i received a good results that being cured from herpes virus, I am highly heal thank Dr Kuda I am the happiest woman on earth today, you can also contact him and ask for help Emai: [email protected] OR his Call/Text Number +1 (346) 478-1991 his Website https://drkudaspelltemple.wixsite.com/my-site-kuda
I am so glad writing this article today to tell the world how i was cured from HSV VIRUS, I was diagnosed with HSV-1&2 for three years before Dr Timothy cured me with his herbal roots and herbs precaution which he sent to me through DHL delivery service…( a herbal drink and a tree root branch) if you are going through same situation you can contact him on his website https://5dc41d5b6d60d.site123.me or email [email protected] herpes is such a nasty virus.